Wednesday, June 18, 2008

June 2008 - LC’s Lending Performance

I just went through my account details, and using Excel’s xirr function determined that my Prosper Lending ROI stands at 7.88% at the moment.

I was a little surprised at the result, considering I’ve picked up more late borrowers since I last reported. Fortunately the ROI still manages to hover between 7.5% - 8.0%. It is also hovering between the two ROI estimates given by Eric and Lendingstats. (7.57% and 8.68%)


When using the xirr function, I count all loans that are one month late or worse to have $0 loan value. I also included 2 loans that were less than one month late because they have the dreaded “Bankruptcy” tag next to them. Erg…

Below is a little more info on my late loans that I am writing off at the moment. Any extra payments squeezed out by the Collection Agency Amsher at this point will be considered a blessing. Also, based on Prosper’s last bad debt sale attempt, these loans, for all practical purposes, have zero value to anybody but me anyway. I hope I get some more payments out of these deadbeats.


Well, here’s to my current borrowers that they remain current.

*LC eats a banana*

Tuesday, June 17, 2008

In Their Own Words II

More selections from recent Prosper listings.


"I am a good candidate for this loan because… it's a small loan and I'm using it for financial reasons."


"I am a good candidate for this loan because I have a steady, long term job and I pay my bills I would just like to stop paying so much interest."


"I am a good candidate for this loan because I am a very loving father and want the best vacation for her."


"With the last loan I paided off my overdue bills except one that i must of missed for a smaal amount. I am takeing care of that now."


"I can work in all 52 states and most building department are seeking qualified people."


"I am a good steward and truly just need a chance to continue to make my dream come true! "


"I am a good candidate for this loan because I am a person who works very hard. "


"I make my payments on time and pay everything threw the internet or can be withdrawn from my bank account. "


"This loan will be used to… help catch up on my mortgage so I don't loose my house. "


"I am a good candidate for this loan because… everyone deserves a second chance. "


"I am a good candidate for this loan because I have very few bills. "


"I am a good candidate for this loan because… I have full time job and no mortgage to payment. and welling within less than two yrs. "


"I am a good candidate for this loan because.....I am a single parent trying to make way for me and my child. "


"We’ve put as much on credit cards as we can, we’ve borrowed all that we can from our loved ones, and we’ve even gotten a small bank loan to keep things going. So rest assured that we’ve undertaken every funding option possible before resorting to Prosper. "


"HELP!! I got more info! IM A good risk!!!"


"This loan would pay off 4 credit cards with a combined total of 78.43% interest. "


"However, this prosper loan would improve my financial standing as as my current payments on all this debt greatly exceed what I can pay."


"The reason I have chosen the prosper community for funding again is because their are lenders who are willing to give individuals like myself who may not have the best credit a second chance."


"I am currently paying over $600.00 per month in interest alone. "


"I am a good candidate for this loan because of know finances. i have my degree in finance from stonehill college. "


"I am starting a new job and need help paying rent, car, bills, food etc, until I begin getting my paychecks in about 3 weeks "


"This loan will help me get that collections charge off off of my credit report and get it paid ASAP. Once this is cleared up, my boyfriend and I should be debt free and be able to afford a wedding."


"PLEASE HELP US FROM DROWNING."


"The bankruptcy was discharged in October 2005. "


"This loan will be used to run sub prime lending business. "


"This loan will be used toward a $4000 operation for our sweet dog, Maggie Mae. "


"I am a good candidate for this loan because… although my credit rating is low now, I have consistently paid my bills on time for several years now and do not ever want to fall behind in any of my financial obligations again. "


"I am borowing this money mostly for fun to see hwo it works before I start lending money. "


"This loan will be used to pay off my current prosper loan as well as a few payday loans that I foolishly took out again. "


"Pretty please with sugar on top!!?!? "


"I have been working to improve myself but these loans are killing me, Please help. "


"I was previously very successful at this health consulting business, however a few years ago, the timing wasn't right yet. Now the time is right! "


"I am not high risk, I am a good investment! "


"My credit score is only 586, but if you look closer you'll find that I do pay my instalment loans as scheduled. "


"I am a good candidate for this loan because… I'm dedicated in getting on the right path "


"Well, now it is your turn. My family and I need your help to get back together. "


"I just would like to start my life over. "

Tuesday, June 10, 2008

May 08 Warm n Fuzzy Index

May 08 Warm n Fuzzy Index:
57% - 40/70
(Last month's reading: 61%)


8/10 - Personal Performance: No Change.

6/10 - Peer Performance: No Change.

7/10 - Prosper Management: No Change. Nothing going on.

8/10 - Platform Improvement: -2 this month. Not too much on the improvements side this month.

Back-end updates – Booorrring…

Institutional Lending interface – What happened to P2P lending?

2/10 - Listing Selection/Volume: -1 this month. Despite going nationwide last month, listing volume is back down to where it was before the change. That doesn’t make much sense. Where are all the borrowers?

2/10 - External Influences: No Change. The economy still sucks. Inflation. Oil prices…

7/10 - Viability Forecast:
No Change.


Summary: Not too much happened in May. Meh…

See you next month!


Past Index Readings:
61% - April 2008
54% - March 2008
54% - February 2008
46% - January 2008
43% - December 2007
50% - November 2007
57% - October 2007
54% - September 2007

What is the Warm n Fuzzy Index?

Friday, June 6, 2008

5.10% Not Attractive to Prosper Lenders

Despite a record setting May 08, Prosper’s Conservative Portfolio Plan isn’t attracting much interest (pun).

It could be because the estimated return is only 5.10%.


There is a recent listing falling within the Conservative Plan. The interest rate offered on the listing is not high enough to attract PP bids from PP lenders that did not update their PP specifications and are still using the old minimum bid rates. So this listing will only receive bids from those using the new PP metrics.


This listing only generated 8 PP bids, seen firing at 9:24 PM on June 5, 2008. In the past I’ve seen PP bids fund entire listings at the minimum bid rate. That doesn’t appear to be the case anymore.

Prosper, if you’re listening, the PP rates on the conservative slice are too low…

Prosper Set Some Records in May 08

If you follow Prosper stuff, you should have already heard by now that May 08 became Prosper’s largest month for loan originations. Over $9.5 million in loans originated last month, besting April 07, which was the previous high.

It took Prosper over a year to set a new originations record. Not exactly stellar (nor consistent) growth, but there’s more going on in the background. Let’s take a look…


While April 07 was the previous high month, only about 1/3 of April 07’s loan originations fell within Prosper’s “Select Index”. (The Select Index is a set of loans defined by Prosper which fall within the credit grades AA-E, have 0 current delinquencies, 0-3 recent inquiries, and 40% or less DTI.)


You can see from the graph that since Oct. / Nov. 07 the Select Index’s share of total originations has increased substantially. This is most likely due to Prosper’s Portfolio Plans.

Nearly 2/3 of all originations in May 08 fell within Prosper’s “Select Index”. Wow. So not only was May 08 a record month in total originations, but it also set a record in the Select Index’s share of that pie. That means more quality loans have been funding, and that’s pretty good news.


Now let’s look at the origination growth of Select Index loans:


Comparing the amount of Select Index loans funded in May 08 and April 07, you can see that the volume has more than doubled. Again, a very positive sign, and another record.


One last graph. Fred93 likes to show a graph of the month-by-month late loan fraction, which you can find here. Instead of looking at all loans, let’s see how those Select Index loans have been performing (on the same scale):


While not perfect, the late loan rate of Select Index loans isn’t nearly as bad as the performance of all loans together. I can’t imagine what a graph of non-Select Index loans would look like…yikes.

*** I should note the performance graph above does not include repurchased loans, many of which (about 60) are part of Prosper’s Suit Test. Of the 60 repurchased loans, at the moment 28 have been identified by listing number. Of these 28, only 5 fall within Prosper’s Select Index. So, while these repurchased loans are missing from the data, the impact from these loans is not very high.***

Wednesday, June 4, 2008

In Their Own Words

More samples from potential borrowers at Prosper.


"I am a good candidate for this loan because… im a hard worker and good citizen"


"The current negative accounts are all due to a discharged Chapter 7 Bankruptcy. They are showing negative but they were discharged over a year ago."


"This loan will be used to… pay off credit cards that would provide me the opportunity to live more independently without stress."


"I am a good candidate for this loan because… I HAVE GROWN TO BE A VERY RESPOSSIBLE PERSON."


"I have had bad past history, but I am ready to get my act together and be completely responsible for this and the financial security of my children."


"I am a good candidate for this loan because I am working on increasing my credit and have not faultered in over a year."


"HELP MY GRANDAUGHTER RETURN TO COLLEGE, FATHER IS AN ALCOHOLIC AND MOTHER IS DECEASED"


"Please see it in your heart to help me out!"


"My husband works full time as a construction manager. I am a stay-at-home mom to a wonderful 2 year old son."


"I need now to pay off a few small items so that I will be completely out of debt:)!"


"After I pay off those debts, I can Refinance my house so I can afford it, since my adjustable rate mortgage ARM just jumped waaay up.."


"I need help paying the bills this month until I can get healthy and get back to work."


"This loan will be used to… retain a lawyer because my husband of 15years, is divorcing me and is trying to take everything."


"Which caused me to get behind on some bills. BK was dischared 7/2007."


"My name Kimberly."


"I have my spouse income to repay this loan"


"Since I am divorced I will not have to worry about my ex wife’s spending habits"


"Please Help! I am relisting my loan and asking for the kindness of all of you here on Prosper for your help."


"I am a good candidate for this loan because after BK I haven't had any problems with credit."


"This loan will be used to pay on my mortgage, car notes, and bills…"


"This loan will be used to give my wife and kids the house they all deserve."


"I always pay my bills ontime i'm never late, I was a home owner and got screwed on the the deal so now its forclosed. Other then that i always pay all my bills when they are due or way before."


"WE REALLY need your help today."


"I mest up my credit at a very young age but since then i have payed off my cards."


"My family is number 1 and I will do anything to help them even if that means going into debt. I LOVE THEM!"